Log in

No account? Create an account

January 2019



Powered by LiveJournal.com

My girl’s from Vassar…Jean Webster

Most people will have heard of Jean Webster’s most famous book, Daddy-Long-Legs even if they haven’t read it. Some will even know the sequel, Dear Enemy. I know I have copies of both and have wasted time in a fruitless search for them. They must still be in a box! The Patty books are much less well known and I’d never read them, so when I found they were available as free downloads for the Kindle I snapped them up.

When Patty Went to College (Patty & Priscilla in Britain) was published in 1903 and Just Patty in 1911. This is the wrong reading order as Just Patty is set at a school, St Ursula’s and When Patty went to College er, at college as you’d expect. Webster used her own experiences at The Lady Jane Grey School and at Vassar for background and colour. Patty Wyatt is a very different character from either Jerusha Abbott, the rescued orphan or Sally McBride, the social reformer. She whirls through life, always surrounded by friends, looked to as a leader and not appearing to take anything seriously.

Just Patty is definitely a school story, but very different from any English one you’re likely to have read. (For comparison, Angela Brazil’s first book, A Terrible Tomboy was published in 1904.) The American girls seem to spend a lot more time organizing social events then their English counterparts; they have lessons in ‘manners’; they have far more freedom to go out of bounds and to receive correspondence from whom they please. There’s no plodding arrival at school and then working her way up for Patty. She’s there fully formed, as it were and already an established school character when the book starts. You’d be looking a long time for any idea of schoolgirl honour or earnestness about work or games (although the girls seem to take basketball seriously).

Patty has a great way of turning the tables on the teachers. Miss Lord, the Latin teacher, is keen on sociology: Miss Lord was the one who struck the modern note at St. Ursula's. She believed in militant suffragism and unions and boycotts and strikes; and she labored hard to bring her little charges to her own advanced position. When Patty finds another girl in tears over learning eighty lines of Virgil, she tells the girls to strike for sixty lines on the grounds that Miss Lord should see the sense of it because ‘we’re just like the laundry girls’. "You, Miss Lord, will appreciate the fairness of our demands better than any of the other teachers, because you believe in unions.” Poor Miss Lord, hoist with her own petard. A compromise is reached but there’s no doubt that Patty is the victor. She has a wonderful knack of being popular with the girls and amusing the staff so that they tolerate her many breaches of the rules. Patty thinks trivial rules are just made to be broken, but she does nothing underhand or dishonourable. She has a lot in common with Rose Red of What Katy Did at School but is nicer, kinder and less irritating.

When Patty Went to College is something of a misnomer. As with the school story she is already well established at college and will soon be leaving. The book opens with her breaking as many college rules as possible in the way she chooses to decorate her room, a feat she achieves by twisting the janitor around her little finger. It’s never explicitly stated, but she’s obviously a very attractive girl. Again, the girls seem to spend a great deal of time organising theatricals and other entertainments rather than working for their exams. The American college system of that time is confusing to an English reader. Instead of going to lectures and taking notes they are expected to ‘make recitations’ i.e. state what they know/translate in class, a nerve-wracking experience for many of them. Patty of course is up to anything and her quick mind and ready tongue deceive many a lecturer. She’s very bright and manages to appear to do no work at all. We never do learn her final results or what she plans to do after college but in the last chapter she has a sudden epiphany after a chat with a visiting bishop. As a result of this she decides to grow up and avoid the ‘subterfuges’, the not-quite- lies she has used to get out of awkward situations.

Both books are episodic; snapshots of Patty’s various adventures without any plotline. By the end of the second book I liked Patty much more than I did at first (disapproving old Puritan, me) and decided the stories were fun and not to be taken as serious depictions of school/college life as Webster herself experienced it.

I also downloaded Jerry (Jerry Junior) but haven’t read it yet.


Must read these Barbara. I finally found the Canadian one - Judy of York Hill - also very different from UK school stories!
That sounds an interesting one.
I have at least one of the Patty books, although it's been a while since I read it. I do remember being struck by the difference between American school life as depicted and the British version, and longed to find more examples of this type of literature.
There's the Friendly Terrace/Peggy Raymond series, by Harriet Lummis Smith. The first one was published in 1912. I think some are available on Project Gutenberg.


Patty and Priscilla

I don't remember a time when I didn't love Patty and Priscilla, and Judy Abbott and Sally McBride. I was brought up on them and read them every year, just for love.
I was really upset when I heard that Jean Webster died in childbirth, though the baby survived. Also, Patty was said to be based on a college friend who also died very young.
There's something satisfying to think that they live on and are still loved anyway.


Re: Patty and Priscilla

Yes, sad that Jean Webster died young. Judging by her books she was great fun, as well as having a keen social conscience.


A school story, compared with What Katy Did at School and free on Kindle! I'm off the amazon NOW! Thank you so much!

Penny (Scottish Vegan Homemaker)