?

Log in

No account? Create an account
gertrude

April 2018

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
thinking

Reading Failures



Do you ever have times when you keep starting books and then not getting on with them? I’ve had one of these spells since I finished The Return of Captain John Emmett. The first attempt was with A Confederacy of Dunces by John Kennedy Toole, one of my 30p wonders from a local charity stall. It’s published as a Penguin Modern Classic and praised all round. The chief protagonist is a monster of a man, Ignatius Reilly: grotesquely fat, gluttonous, bone idle, bizarrely dressed, thirty years old and still parasitically dependent on his mother, whom he treats abominably. His intelligence is twisted so as to be out of kilter with the whole modern world; he believes it’s been all downhill since the middle ages. He’s also obsessed with the state of his gut and refers constantly to his troublesome ‘valve’. ‘Are you fooling with that valve again? Nobody else got him a valve but you. I ain’t got no valve.’ says his poor mother. What kept me reading for a while was the unusual style of the writing. Then the author made the fatal mistake of including in the novel pages of Ignatius’ own writings. These are necessarily ravings and extremely tedious. I don’t care who the author is, Angela Brazil or A S Byatt, it is in my opinion always a mistake to replicate a character’s own novel, poetry or whatever. I can see why some people regard Ignatius as a great comic character but he was too much for me. His mother is much funnier.

My second book failed me for almost the same reason. In The Birds Fall Down by Rebecca West, the chief character is Laura Rowan, daughter of an English MP and a Russian mother. Soon after the story begins, in about 1900, Laura travels to Paris with her mother to stay with her grandparents. Preserve us from Russian exiles! Poor Laura has to listen for hours to her potty grandfather carrying on about the inferiority of everything in the western world compared with the glories of Mother Russia. Unfortunately the reader has to suffer with her as page after page is filled with the old man's rants. It is brilliant in its way as a depiction of character but there is just too much of it to be borne. I am still picking the book up every now and then and reading a few more pages, but it’s heavy going and I’m not hopeful of finishing it.



Anything you’ve given up on recently?

Comments

Anything you’ve given up on recently?

Almost, but as I'm now more than halfway I'm still sticking with The Girl Who Kicked The Hornet's Nest by Stieg Larsson. I really can't wait for it to be finished but I can't bring myself to stop reading it either.

Re: Anything you’ve given up on recently?

What a dilemma! It seems you either love or hate Stieg Larsson. I've never tried him so can't judge.

Re: Anything you’ve given up on recently?

Oh, I love him and I really enjoyed the first two books. This last one is twice the size and there's a lot of political plot which is heavy going. The bits in between are great :)
The Everlasting Story of Nory by Nicholson Baker. I picked it up at a book fair in 1999 because it looked cute. Last year when I finally decided to read it I couldn't get past page 30, it was just too boring. After it had been languishing for months on my bedside table I gave up.
Quite right. Too many other good books waiting to be read.
Gosh, different strokes - I loved that one and I'm always forcing it on other people!
Aw, haha. I'm sorry if I stepped on your heart!

But I must say, nice as it is to have someone agree with my likes and dislikes, it's also nice that there is variety in tastes and that no book is universally shunned.