?

Log in

No account? Create an account
gertrude

December 2017

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
reading

The Summer Before the War, Helen Simonson



The Summer Before the War is set in Rye, that charming Sussex coastal town which features so often in fiction. There’s a well established community with a great distrust of incomers. One of the latter is Beatrice. Used to having money, responsibility and respect while travelling with her father, since his death she has become penniless. Highly educated, independent-minded, she is offered the post of Latin teacher at the grammar school in Rye, thanks to the support of two women who sit on the Board of Governors.

Beatrice is introduced to the town by her patroness ‘Aunt Agatha’. She is the slightly eccentric aunt of Hugh and Daniel, active in town matters and constantly trying to get one over ghastly Mrs Fothergill the Mayor’s wife. Her husband, Uncle John, is one of the nicest characters in the book. He’s rarely at home in Rye because his important work at the Foreign Office keeps him in London. Hugh is a trainee surgeon, highly thought of by the surgeon he works under. Ambitious, he imagines himself marrying his superior’s daughter and having a Harley Street practice. His cousin Daniel is his opposite in character: a little wild, madly attractive, hoping to be a successful poet.

It’s 1914. The townspeople first refuse to believe a war possible, then become wildly enthusiastic, welcoming Belgian refugees, enjoying triumphalist parades and organising committees. A year later, everything has changed as the realities of war come home with the casualty lists.

Rye is beautifully described, the characters well defined, their fates a matter of concern. If I have a criticism of the book it’s that there are too many themes: the independence of women; attitudes to illegitimacy and to homosexuality; small town politics; the effects of war on individuals and the town community. It’s also impossible to escape the dead hand of E F Benson and his depiction of Rye as Tilling. Reading of a large car in the narrow street, you can’t help thinking of the Wyses. The famous writer living in what is obviously Lamb House is called Mr Tillingham. The spats between Aunt Agatha and Mrs Fothergill are comparable with those between Mapp and Lucia. There’s even a Quaint Irene character, Miss Finch. This is all amusing but perhaps distracts attention from the main theme: the futures of Beatrice, Hugh and Daniel. A good book but a little overambitious.

I read this book courtesy of Random House via NetGalley.
Helen Simonson is the author of Major Pettigrew’s Last Stand, which I reviewed here.

The publishers of this book were insistent that my review be published on and not before 22nd March. OK, they’ve sent the book to my Kindle and I’ve been able to read it early, so I benefit. OTOH it’s tiresome to have to remember when a post should go up. They are not the only publishers taking this bossy tone with their unpaid reviewers. ‘Please publish your review on your blog, Amazon and Goodreads on …and send a link to …’ I’m not even on Goodreads! It’s easy enough to put a shorter review on Amazon but you then expose yourself to critical comments from people who spend their time on the net looking for things to disagree with. Plus, I've just checked on Amazon and the book is apparently not out until the 24th. You can't review a book on Amazon until it's been released, so there's another date to remember. The time may come when I feel this game isn’t worth the candle.

Comments

That's the second time this book has come up today, only I can't remember whether the first time was an email from Amazon, someone on Twitter, or what. Clearly the publisher's efforts to Generate Buzz are working!
And I'm helping!
It's certainly making me think 'hmm, I might enjoy this'!
I have been looking forward to this one since you first posted about it a while ago. I'm off to buy a Kindle copy now.
In spite of my criticisms, I did enjoy it. The period feel is well done.

(Anonymous)

My copy just came from Book Depository so I'll come back and read this after I've read it.