callmemadam (callmemadam) wrote,
callmemadam
callmemadam

A Single Thread, Tracy Chevalier



I wanted to read this book because it was recommended by someone whose judgement I usually trust. I was very disappointed. I read elsewhere that Tracy Chevalier spends six months researching a novel before she starts writing. To my mind, research for a novel (as opposed to non-fiction), should be done and then put away; the information is there to draw on and to prevent errors. In this novel, the research *is* the story. We get a complete guided tour of Winchester cathedral, instructions on how to make a tapestry kneeler for a church and lessons in bell ringing. When Dorothy L Sayers wrote The Nine Tailors (listed here as a source), she did a huge amount of research into bell ringing, really mastered it, yet this erudition never intrudes; it’s just necessary background. A Single Thread is, frankly, dull and at one point I nearly gave up on it.

The biggest problem with the book is the main character, Violet. She’s thirty-eight, her brother and her fiancé have been killed in the First World War and she lives at home with her ghastly mother. At last, she breaks away, taking her typing skills from Southampton to Winchester, where she has a go at making a new life for herself, a life for one of the ‘surplus women’ of the time. I found her not only uninteresting but unbelievable; I just couldn’t see things working out as they did at that period of time. This is a great shame but no matter what I think, the book will probably be a bestseller anyway, on the strength of the author’s name.

A Single Thread was published in September and I read it thanks to NetGalley.
Tags: netgalley, tracy chevalier
Subscribe

  • Found in Books 13: The Book Club Newsletter

    I see I last did one of these posts in 2012. A sad reflection on how much harder it is to buy old books these days. Last week, I bought a book on…

  • The Daffodil Affair, Michael Innes

    Michael Innes (the academic J I M Stewart), is hardly a neglected crime writer; I’ve had a lot of his books in green Penguin crime editions over…

  • Today's book bargain

    Evelyn Waugh's Decline and Fall is 99p for the kindle today. Waugh's frontispiece for the book.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments