callmemadam (callmemadam) wrote,

  • Mood:
I have just read The Lost Art of Keeping Secrets by Eva Rice, which was recommended by people who like the same sorts of books as I do. It comes very prettily packaged: even the page edges are pink, which would usually put me off. (But if you judged a book by its cover you would miss out on Hilary McKay's wonderful Saffy’s Angel.) The blurb on the back cover claims that the book is ‘in the tradition of Nancy Mitford and I Capture the Castle’. In their dreams. It is much more like Jilly Cooper, only not as good.

I did enjoy the book but it loses steam half way through and it was then that the constant use of anachronistic language really began to annoy me. In 1954, would anyone have described a snowy scene as “pure Narnia”, or assumed that everyone would understand a reference to Gandalf? True, Lewis’s and Tolkien’s books had been published, but they were not common currency as they are today. I also imagine that the proprietor of a London café at the time would have been pretty surprised to be asked for a hamburger and a glass of wine. I can’t believe that a gently-reared girl like Penelope, just out of school, would have made a joke about a ‘well hung’ picture, but the author couldn’t resist her own wit.

In spite of nods to Princess Margaret, Hancock’s Half Hour and Good Housekeeping magazine plus knowing hints that this new American singer Elvis Presley will be big one day, there is very little period feel to the book. I don’t know how to classify it: not quite historical fiction, not quite a modern romance. For genuine 1950s zeitgeist, try That Uncertain Feeling by Kingsley Amis; for an upper class romp, read Pandora by Jilly Cooper. If you want to read about how the War affected an upper class family living in the country, read One Fine Day by Mollie Panter-Downes. (This was first published in 1947 but is easy to find because it was reissued by Virago.) The Lost Art is not as good as any of these, but I shall probably read it again, which must explain its success.

Tags: books, chicklit, eva rice

  • Reminder

    The new Furrowed Middlebrow books are out today!

  • The Thursday Murder Club, Richard Osman

    There’s a huge number of books being published in one go just at the moment, because of the Covid backlog, so the fight for readers (and buyers)…

  • V for Victory, Lissa Evans

    It’s 1944 and doodlebugs are falling randomly on an increasingly crumbling and dirty London. Noel and Vee, whom we left at the end of Crooked…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment